As I posted earlier, the Armenian Gay and Lesbian Association of New York has sponsored historic petition co-signed by 20+ leading Armenian cultural figures who have unified their voices to support human rights in Armenia. This is the first time such a petition has been created in support of LGBT human rights in Armenia.
Chairman of Golden Apricot International Film Festival, one of my favourite film-makers, prominent Canadian Armenian director Atom Egoyan is among those who co-signed the petition.
It has since been supported by more than 300 (at the time of writing this post) Armenian and foreign citizens, including well known activists, cultural, art figures.
Comments are being posted under the petition by people who signed it.
Here is a very touching one by Christine Allen:
My great-grandfather, Shukrey Sanjiyan, was brutally attacked during a pogrom in Tarsus on November 15, 1895. He managed to survive and made his way to the U.S. via France in 1897. The rest of his family was slaughtered during the genocide. It is in his memory that I, his lesbian great-granddaughter, sign this petition. My wife and I have been together for over 26 years and our youngest daughter, Kalie Sanjiyan, carries his name. I work for equal rights for all people in America, and I support equal rights for all people in the homeland of my heart, Armenia.
As writers, artists, intellectuals, and concerned members of the Armenian diaspora (and beyond), we add our names to this petition to express our outrage over the censorship of Hovhannes Ishkhanyan's novel Demob Day by the Military Police in Armenia and by various bookstores in Yerevan. Freedom of expression is the bedrock of any democracy; the interrogation of an author and the removal of literature from bookshelves harkens back to the primitive, brutal, unenlightened, and fearful days of Stalinism and Fascism.
Literature is one means by which an open society examines, discusses and debates the problems it faces. A celebration of the five hundred year anniversary of books in Armenia rings hollow at this time when even one book, dealing with a timely and crucial issue of Armenian society, does not have a chance of being read.
We urge the authorities involved, including the Ministry of Culture and the Central Military Prosecutor's Office of Armenia, to drop their pursuit of charging Ishkhanyan with Article 263 of the Criminal Code of Armenia (the illegal dissemination of pornographic materials or items). We stand behind our fellow writers in Armenia as they defend Ishkhanyan and will watch this case carefully to offer further support in keeping literature in Armenia free from blatant intrusions and threats from the government.
Starting with the case of that Nubarashen school pedophile teacher, then army and school abuse videos, and then the highly publicised recent domestic violence case, what I noticed - not infrequently - that some people, even among ‘stop violence’ campaigners, in the heat of emotional debate call for lynching of those suspected in abuse or violence.
Yes, it’s understandable that emotions may run high, and things may be said (but not meant to) in the midst of heated debate or as an immediate emotional reaction to horrific crimes.... But you simply can’t fight violence with violence. This will not solve any problems. Instead, it will ensure a vicious circle of everlasting violence.
Let’s take a very recent example of domestic violence in Armenia, that rightly resulted in an outrage, and petition was launched (I supported and signed it) calling for law against domestic violence.
In total, there were 3196 signatures with/without comments, now passed to the prime minister.
A friend of mine disturbed by certain comments posted on the petition 'Armenia Must Pass Domestic Violence Legislation', compiled a list of all of those signatories (28 in total) who "wished bodily violence and death upon the husband and/or mother-in-law of Zaruhi Petrosyan". He rightly pointed out that “we need to prevent domestic violence, not practice lynch mob rule”.
It is also disturbing that a person (e.g. petition signatory 3179, screenshot below) would use a slanderous and bigoted term about a sexual minority group to express his anger over a domestic violence issue. This ‘injustice by injustice’ approach totally devalues his own signature.
Thankfully, 28 comments make up less than 1% of the total number of signatories.
Interesting geographical distribution of such comments: 22 of the 28 comments came from California(!); 2 from Armenia; 1 from Turkey, Australia each; and 1 from the states of Wisconsin and Florida each. As friend commented, “Americans seem to be the most 'stop violence with violence' people...in a country where the death sentence is practiced regularly, but I am not sure about in California....”
Below are just few selected extracts to demonstrate the point.
No. 3,152 They should be thrown in jail and beaten so it's a lesson to others.
No. 2,787 I would beat the living hell out of this prick and set his mother on fire!
No. 2,763 That man and his disgusting mother should be beaten the same way and crushed to death.
No. 2,553 Maybe it's not only time to sign a petition, maybe it's time to personally fight back. Go get your bats and your guns, grab your pots and your pans, they work too, and turn around and do what Madea says. Beat them back!!
No. 2,406 This mother and son should be charge with first degree murder and death penalty sentense for them they should hang in middle of town
No. 1,815 Put a piece of cloth in his mouth take him toYerevan city square and pull his nails in front of the public then hang him
Or, for example, No. 484:
In the past, I heard of Arab females being stoned to death and even seen a true story about it "The Stoning of Soraya M". But I never heard an Armenian version of it. I can't believe beating an individual to death still occures with a mother-in-law having to be the main suspect.
Saying that, and presumably considering it deploring, she then continues:
It's sad to say, but in my personal opinion I believe she should get beaten the same way and let along to die. Don't only stick a dirty peice of cloth in her mouth, but stick in up her ass. The mother-in-law as well as her xangarvats son need to die exectution style. The best method for these types of people is Iranian style "stone to death".
Rule of law, education, trainings, changes in law, and similar measures... that's what I'd like to see instead.
*Thanks to T.S. for help in preparing this blog post.
Truly, there are no limits of absurdity in the way Armenian legal system and police work. Examples? Plenty... For example: You get attacked, then YOU are detained as an ‘attacker’. Now the most recent one: You uncovered the evidence of sexual abuse and other irregularities at one of Armenia’s boarding schools, then from being a witness YOU are becoming a defendant charged with libel. That’s exactly what happened with Mariam Sukhudyan, environmental activist better known for Save Teghut Forest campaign.
EcoLur: Mariam Sukhudyan, the youth green movement activist of S.O.S Tegout, was summoned on 15 August to Erebouni Criminal Investigation Department to give an interview concerning the charge of libel in accordance with Part 1, Article 135 of the Criminal Code of RA.
On 13 November 2008, the Public TV Channel prepared a program where one of the pupils at Nubarashen Boarding School № 11 told about sexual harassment by the teacher. The TV program used video fragments submitted activists of S.O.S Teghout who are also engaged with the protection of the rights of vulnerable social layers. Based on this TV program, Erebouni Criminal Investigation Department conducted an investigation, and as a result, the criminal case №12105809 was initiated on 11 February 2009. However, the charge was not sexual harassment, but libel in accordance with Part 1, Article 135 of the Criminal Code of RA. Mariam Sukhudyan and other volunteers of the green movement were summoned as witnesses to this case in May 2009.
However, Mariam Suhkudyan received a summons on 13 August 2009, that says she is to appear to Erebouni Criminal Investigation Department as an accused.
“EcoLur” calls on to the public at large, including state bodies to pay appropriate attention to this case and reminds that the democratization process declared by the President of our country supposes the participation of the public in the country governance, and S.O.S. signals are one of its manifestation forms.
Mariam was among group of young people who volunteered at the Nubarashen boarding school N11 during April - June 2008 within the UN "10 Best Schools" project.
Below is a video aired by Public TV of Armenia on 13 November 2008 reflecting the allegations of sexual abuse in that school.
On 15 November 2008 a petition was posted on Big Family blog signed by those young people, uncovering various irregularities and allegations of abuse they witnessed while working as volunteers at the school.
An Unhealthy Atmosphere at the Nubarashen Boarding School Petition
We, the group of young people, have worked on voluntarily basis in Nubarashen Boarding School #11 for children with special needs from April - to June, 2008 within the UN "10 Best Schools" project. We want to bring your attention to a number of problems encountered at the school-- problems to which we cannot stay indifferent. We were able to identify and analyze these problems as a result of the frequent visits and our close relationship with the children.
Education Although the school is meant to host children with special needs, in our opinion, there are also perfectly healthy schoolchildren at the school. We do not find this situation acceptable, as the children with special needs receive a special education program, and as a result the healthy children do not receive a full education. The overall level of education in the school is very low. Many of the graduating schoolchildren do not know how to write, they can hardly read: they are illiterate. We believe this to be not so much a consequence of learning disabilities, but the lack of a caring, decent and attentive teaching process. After a few lessons with the same children, we could easily see the progress through their studies.
School Meals We heard numerous complaints from children regarding the food. We were witness to how they preferred getting by with a piece of bread instead of eating, in their own words, the "disgusting" meals the school provides. It would appear that the meals that the children to not consume is fed to the director's pigs, turkeys and dogs inhabiting the school area. Overall, children are not happy with food and they often stay hungry.
The Hygienic Conditions The air inside the school building is heavy and stinky. During the summer, children take shower twice a week, at best, once a week.
The Treatment of Children According to the stories of the children, they are object to beatings and other forms of physical punishment. We personally witnessed needlessly harsh treatment of the children from teachers and night guards. The school director and other administrative workers use children as a free labour force in their homes and summer houses. Apparently, many of the workers in the school are relatives of the director.
Sexual Assaults We have heard about sexual assault from Armenian language and literature teacher towards high school girls. According to the stories from the girls, there was at least one case of rape. The children assure they have told about this to school administration, but they were not take seriously on account of their mental disabilities.
It is worth mentioning that we have discussed these problems with the school director and personnel. After the talk, our visits to the school became highly undesirable. Meanwhile, the children have been put under pressure to the extent that they even tried to change the stories, although later they confessed they have been told to lie.
Taking into account the above mentioned accounts, we kindly ask you to further explore and to solve the problems as well as to assure our easy access to the school because children have grown attached to us and they feel stressed and anxious when we do not visit them.
On 2 December 2008 they held a press conference in Yerevan detailing the problems outlined above. [Below, via Zhamanak daily (in Armenian)]
Բացվել է Նուբարաշենի թիվ 11 հատուկ դպրոցի վարագույրը. սարսափելի է
Վարագույրը մի թեթեւ բացում ես ու` սարսափում, շնչահեղձ լինում: Ու դա ցանկացած համակարգի` բաց կամ փակ, այդ համակարգի ցանկացած վարչության, օղակի պարագայում: Մի խումբ երիտասարդներ ՄԱԿ-ի «10 լավագույն դպրոց» ծրագրի շրջանակներում կամավորական սկզբունքով աշխատելիս բացեցին Նուբարաշենի թիվ 11 հատուկ դպրոցի վարագույրն ու` իրականությունից անակնկալի եկան: Բայց արագ չիջեցրին վարագույրն ու տեսածից, բացահայտածից շշմած` չլռեցին` ինչպես ընդունված է, ինչպես անում են:
Երեկ «Ուրբաթ» ակումբում նրանք պատմեցին ամեն ինչ:
Նուբարաշենի թիվ 11 հատուկ դպրոցը նախատեսված է մտավոր եւ ֆիզիկական հաշմանդամ երեխաների համար, բայց երիտասարդները, ինտենսիվ շփվելով երեխաների հետ, նկատում են, որ նրանց մեծամասնությունը ոչ միայն նորմալ մտավոր տվյալներ ունի, այլեւ` «մեծ տենչ գիտելիքի հանդեպ»: Սկսում են աշխատել նրանց հետ, սովորեցնել: Կամավորներից մեկը պատմեց, որ աշակերտների հետ 1 ամիս անգլերեն պարապելուց հետո նրանք սովորեցին այբուբենը: Իսկ 2-3 ամսից հետո կարողացան շփվել ամերիկացիների հետ: Կամավորները վաղուց էին զգացել դպրոցի տնօրինության անբարյացակամ վերաբերմունքը. պարբերաբար երիտասարդներին կանչում էին, հարցուփորձ անում` ինչու եք եկել, ինչ եք ուզում... Կամավորները բացատրում են, որ ելնելով մարդասիրական նպատակներից եւ այլն, ցույց են տալիս անհրաժեշտ փաստաթղթեր ու վկայականներ: Միեւնույնն է` կամավորների ներկայությունը դպրոցում անցանկալի էր, անհանգստացնող: Մի օր աշակերտուհիներից մեկը փաթաթվում է կամավոր աղջիկներից մեկին ու ասում. «Ես ձեզ շատ եմ սիրում, բայց մեզ արգելել են շփվել ձեզ հետ»... Սակայն կամավորներն արդեն հասցրել էին շատ բան իմանալ, պարզել դպրոցում կատարվածից:
Նախ, նկատել էին, որ աշակերտները կիսաքաղց են մնում: Հետո երեխաները պատմում են, որ օրվա վերջում իրենք իրենց ձեռքով իրենց համար պատրաստված ճաշը տանում են տնօրենի խոզերին ու հնդկահավերին: Ուտել այդ կերակուրները հնարավոր չէր:
Կամավորներին ասել էին, որ դպրոցում սովորում են 110 աշակերտներ: Երիտասարդները ոչ միայն չեն տեսնում դպրոցում այդքան աշակերտ, այլեւ շատ հաճախ նկատում են արդեն ծանոթ աշակերտների բացակայությունը: Պարզվում է` տղաներին տանում են ուսուցիչների, տնօրենի այգիներում աշխատեցնելու, աղջիկներին` տներում:
Դասուսուցումը չի կարող բավարարել անգամ մտավոր հաշմանդամ երեխաներին, ուր մնաց` լիարժեք երեխային: Աշակերտները պատմել էին, որ ստուգումների ժամանակ իրենք` միանգամայն առողջ երեխաները, ուսուցիչների ցուցումով տկարամիտի դեր են խաղում, եւ որ դա չափազանց զվարճալի է:
Դասերից հետո բոլորին փակում են մի սենյակում, միացնում հեռուստացույցն ու հորդորում սերիալ նայել: Դուրս գալը, զբոսնելը, օրը ուրիշ զբաղմունքներով լցնելը արգելվում է: Սենյակներում, ողջ դպրոցում ծանր հոտ է տարածված: Սանիտարահիգիենիկ տարրական կանոնները չեն պահպանվում. սենյակները հազվադեպ են մաքրվում, երեխաները ուշ-ուշ են լողանում:
Պարապմունքների ընթացքում կամավորների հետ մտերմացած աշակերտուհիները պատմում են ուսուցիչների կողմից կատարված սեռական ոտնձգությունների, բռնաբարության փորձերի մասին: Եվ բոլոր աշակերտուհիները նշում են իրենց հայոց լեզվի եւ գրականության ուսուցչի անունը` Լեւոն Ավագյան: Կամավորները պատմում են տնօրենին: Սա ասում է, որ այդ պատմությունները աղջիկների վառ երեւակայության արդյունքն է, չէ՞ որ նրանք ամբողջ օրը սերիալ են նայում:
Երիտասարդները դիմում են նաեւ հոգեւորականների, ՄԱԿ-ի ներկայացուցիչների, լրագրողների: Հանրային հեռուստաընկերությունը եթեր է հեռարձակում կամավորների նկարահանած տեսաերիզը` քողարկելով իր հետ կատարվածի մասին պատմող աղջկա դեմքը: Դրանից հետո հայոց լեզվի ուսուցիչ Լեւոն Ավագյանը հեռանում է դպրոցից` այլեւս ստեղծագործական աշխատանքներով զբաղվելու նպատակով: Ոչ Լ.Ավագյանը, ոչ մյուս ուսուցիչները, ոչ դպրոցի տնօրենը պատասխանատվության չեն կանչվում: Ոստիկանության Էրեբունու քննչական բաժնից պատասխանատվության են կանչվում կամավոր երիտասարդները` առանց ծանուցագրի, մի հեռախոսազանգով: «Մենք սպասում էինք, որ քննիչները պետք է խիստ մոտեցում ունենային դպրոցի տնօրինության նկատմամբ: Ի վերջո, եթե անգամ դեռ չի ապացուցվել կատարվածը, բայց վկաները շատ են, փաստերը` բազմախոսուն: Այնինչ մենք էինք մեղադրյալի դերում հայտնվել», - պատմեց կամավոր տղաներից մեկը:
«Մեզ հետ կոպիտ վարվեցին եւ շատ վիրավորական: Քննիչ Ադամյանն ասաց, որ ավելի լավ կլիներ մենք ինքնապաշտպանությամբ զբաղվեինք: Հեգնեց, թե մեզ առաքյալների տեղ ենք դրել: Մինչ այդ ես չգիտեի, որ ցուցմունք գրելու համար իրավունք չունեն մեզ 3 ժամից ավել պահելու քննչական բաժնում: Նրանք ինձ այնտեղ պահեցին 7 ժամ», - պատմեց Մարիամ Սուխուդյանը:
Մի խոսքով, երիտասարդներին քննչական բաժնում սպառնացել են, վախեցրել, ասել, որ մեղադրողները` աղջիկները, հրաժարվել են տեսաերիզում պատմածից, եւ որ ամբողջ պատասխանատվությունը իրենց` կամավորների` վարագույրը բարձրացնողների վրա է: Ի դեպ, երիտասարդները ձայնագրել են այն հեռախոսազանգը, որտեղ աղջիկներից մեկը զանգում է կամավորին ու տեղեկացնում, որ ինքը քննչական բաժնում հերքելու է ամեն ինչ, ասելու է, որ կամավորների սովորեցրածով է ինքը նման պատմություններ պատմել, իրականում ոչինչ էլ չի եղել: Եվ որ ինքը ստիպված է այդպես խոսել, քանի որ տնօրենը կանչել է մորը, հոխորտացել, սպառնացել, մայրն էլ ծեծել է իրեն` աշխարհով մեկ խայտառակ անելու համար եւ ստիպել հերքել ամեն ինչ: Աշակերտուհիները արդեն հարցաքննվել են: Նրանք ամեն ինչ հերքել են:
Երեկ ԿԳՆ-ից զանգահարել են կամավորներին, առաջարկել միասին գնալ դպրոց, ստուգայց անցկացնել: Երիտասարդները մերժել են: «Եթե հիմա դուք գնաք այդ դպրոց, կտեսնեք, որ դպրոցը մաքուր է, աշակերտները գոհ են, ոչ մի դժգոհություն չունեն: Բայց այդպես միայն առաջին հայացքից է, հավատացեք»: Երիտասարդների պայքարը գոնե մի արդյունք տվել է. դպրոցը գոնե առժամանակ մաքրվեց գարշահոտերից եւ Լեւոն Ավագյանից:
Ի դեպ, Նուբարաշենի թիվ 11 հատուկ դպրոցն են ավարտել լրագրողներ Գագիկ Շամշյանն ու Մհեր Արշակյանը: Գ.Շամշյանը այդ դպրոց է բերվել Կամոյի, Մ.Արշակյանը` Մեղրիի մանկատնից: Նրանք այդ դպրոց են բերվել իբրեւ տկարամիտներ` համալրելու այդպիսիների գլխաքանակը:
Գագիկ Շամշյանը մինչեւ հիմա հիշում է այդ դպրոցի լավ ու վատ ուսուցիչներին: Եթե անգամ չցանկանա հիշել, ճակատի սպին գոնե ամեն առավոտ հիշեցնելու է լեզվի ուսուցիչ Լեւոն Ավագյանի` մանրահատակի կտորով գլխին հասցրած հարվածը: Մինչեւ հիմա հիշում է ֆիզկուլտուրայի դասատու Վարազդատ Մկրտչյանին, որին երեխաները «կապույտ մորուք» էին ասում, փայտամշակման դասատու Դավիթ Միրզոյանին, որն իր իսկ սարքած ցուցափայտով ծեծում էր իրենց: Եվ թե ինչպես իրենց տանում էր իր այգին, բանջարանոցը, աշխատեցնում, բայց վայը եկել, տարել էր նրան, ով մի պոմիդոր, մի ցոգոլ կպոկեր:
Իսկ ի՞նչ պետք է տեսնի Կրթության եւ գիտության նախարարությունը Նուբարաշենի թիվ 11 հատուկ դպրոցում` մաքուր մանրահատա՞կ, կահկարասի՞, լվացված զուգարաննե՞ր... Ի՞նչ կարող է տեսնել, օրինակ, ԿԳՆ աշխատակից Արծվիկ Արշակյանը, ով նախկինում այդ դպրոցի փոխտնօրենն էր` բռնություննե՞րը, բռնաբարություննե՞րը, առողջ երեխաներին տկարամտացնե՞լը: Նրանք նման բաներ չեն տեսնում. ոչ այն պատճառով, որ ամենակարեւոր բաները աչքով չես տեսնի: Նրանք այնքան ազնիվ են, որ ուրիշի աչքի գերանը տեսնելիս ձայն չեն հանում, որովհետեւ տեսնում են նաեւ իրենց աչքի գերանը:
Լուսանկարը՝ Գագիկ Շամշյանի *photo of Mariam Sukhudyan - via Tert.am
When I first read the news yesterday, I thought it's an intentional (and cleverly made) provocation - a made up story - by environmentalist in Armenia to use names of current and former first ladies to attract more attention and publicity to their cause. Today with all these photocopies of signatures and statements (as per above and below), if confirmed (see, I am still cautious, want to hear confirmations from the first ladies themselves), this could be the most hilarious news of the day.
UPDATE: (4 June 09) First ladies retracted their signature. (see also comments section below)
Armenia’s current and former first ladies have signed a petition against a controversial mining project approved by their husbands, ecologists strongly opposed to its implementation said on Wednesday.
The country’s leading environment protection groups and other non-governmental organizations have for years been campaigning against plans by the Armenian Copper Program (ACP) company to develop a massive copper and molybdenum deposit in the northern Lori region. The Teghut deposit is estimated to contain 1.6 million tons of copper and about 100,000 tons of molybdenum.
The project, if implemented, will lead to the destruction of 357 hectares of rich forest, including 128,000 trees. Critics say that would wreak further havoc on Armenia’s green areas that have already shrunk dramatically since the 1990s. [...]
The non-governmental Committee to Protect Teghut launched last month a fresh campaign against the mining project, collecting signatures in support of its stance. It said on Wednesday that a relevant petition addressed to Armenia’s president, prime minister and parliament speaker has already been signed by about 5,000 citizens, among them First Lady Rita Sarkisian and Kocharian’s wife Bella.
According to Mariam Sukhudian, a member of the committee, the two women agreed to sign the petition as they visited a public park in Yerevan on Tuesday. “We noticed Kocharian’s wife and the current first lady, Rita Sarkisian, there” she told RFE/RL’s Armenian service. “One of our girls, Arpine, approached Bella Kocharian. As soon as she learned what the matter is, she took the paper and signed it. Rita said, ‘Is it about that copper-molybdenum thing?’ and signed it too.”
“We can say that, in a sense, they have joined our movement,” said Sukhudian. “We will scan their signatures and disseminate them through the Internet.” [...]
Reutersreports that a "Turkish prosecutor has opened an investigation that could lead to criminal charges against the authors of an online apology for the World War One killings of Armenians, state-run news agency Anatolian reported on Friday." They could face charges under the infamous Article 301 for "insulting Turkish identity".
"My conscience does not accept the insensitivity showed to and the denial of the Great Catastrophe that the Ottoman Armenians were subjected to in 1915. I reject this injustice and for my share, I empathize with the feelings and pain of my Armenian brothers and sisters. I apologize to them. "
I wrote in my post that even though they did not mention the G-word, this is a remarkable step forward by a group of Turkish thinkers in a country where Armenian Genocide still remains a taboo, albeit a broken one, and where by mere mentioning of the Genocide one could get persecuted or killed.
Here we are. Not only initiators are facing a possible criminal charges (these would possibly be dropped as it would cause an international outrage) but as BBC reports, they are facing now a very real physical threat:
"Police said on Friday they had information that a man arrested this week was gathering intelligence and planning an attack against one of the organisers of the apology campaign.
Police said he had recently travelled to several cities and made it known that he was planning an action that would "shake Turkey", the BBC was told by a source who did not want to be named.
The man's uncle was reportedly among more than 30 people arrested on Wednesday in connection with an alleged ultra-nationalist coup plot.
Documents found in the raids led to the discovery of weapons and explosives in the forest outside Ankara, police say.
Some Turkish writers, who have promoted more open discussion of the Armenian issue, have been targeted by ultra-nationalist Turks.
The Turkish-Armenian writer Hrant Dink was killed last year for openly saying that the events of 1915 were genocide.
Previously he had been tried for "insulting Turkishness" for his comments on 1915."
I posted about the initiative by a group of Turkish intellectuals to launch an online petition personally apologising for 1915 "great disaster" (read genocide) suffered by Armenians. Even though they did not mention the G-word, this is a remarkable step forward by a group of Turkish thinkers in a country where Armenian Genocide still remains a taboo, albeit a broken one, and where by mere mentioning of the Genocide one could get persecuted or killed.
Today The Independentcovered the story saying that "Around 200 Turkish intellectuals and academics are to apologise on the Internet today for the ethnic cleansing of Armenians during the First World War, in the most public sign yet that Turkey's most sensitive taboo is slowly melting away."
This petition was indeed launched today, and the website (in Turkish) opened for signatures now. As BBCindicates, "in the first few hours after the petition was launched, more than 1,000 people had signed their names beneath it."
In fact, numbers are growing. At the time of writing this post, there were 2424 signatories there.
BBC's Sarah Rainsford provides more details to the story in a report entitled Turkish thinkers' Armenia apology: An internet petition has been launched in Turkey, apologising for the "great catastrophe of 1915" when hundreds of thousands of Ottoman Armenians died.
Armenians and many international historians describe as "genocide" the massacres and deaths during a forced deportation from eastern Turkey.
Turkey firmly denies that, saying those killed were just victims of war.
The petition - the first of its kind - was initiated by prominent Turkish academics and newspaper columnists.
They say they want to challenge the official denial and provoke discussion in Turkish society about what happened.
The petition is entitled "I apologise", and a short statement at the top rejects what it calls the ignorance and denial in Turkey of what the Ottoman Armenians suffered in 1915.
It then apologises for the pain that was caused.
It is a bold and original step in a country where writer Hrant Dink was killed just last year for openly saying that the events of 1915 were genocide.
Sparking discussion
Nationalist politicians have condemned the move as an insult to the Turkish nation, and the organisers have received abusive emails.
Turkey admits that many Armenians were killed but it denies any genocide, saying the deaths happened during widespread fighting in World War I.
The petition does not call on the state to apologise for what happened and it deliberately avoids the highly controversial definition of genocide.
But the Turkish academic who dreamed up the idea says he hopes it will spark a proper discussion of what happened and promote empathy for what the Armenians suffered.
Cengiz Aktar called it the responsibility of all Turks to think and talk openly about how, and why, the Armenian people disappeared from a land they inhabited for 4,000 years.
The petition's authors say they have received many encouraging comments.
In the first few hours after the petition was launched, more than 1,000 people had signed their names beneath it.
A group of Turkish intellectuals have apologized for the “great disaster that Ottoman Armenians suffered in 1915” but have fallen short of calling on the state to do the same.
A petition initiated by a group of intellectuals, including professors Baskın Oran and Ahmet İnsel, journalists Ali Bayramoğlu and Cengiz Aktar, personally apologizes for the events.
The group is asking other people to sign the petition, which reads as follows: “I cannot conscientiously accept the indifference to the great disaster that Ottoman Armenians suffered in 1915, and its denial. I reject this injustice and acting of my own will, I share the feelings and pains of my Armenian brothers and sisters, and I apologize to them.”
The organizers of the campaign have underlined that first they will collect signatures from intellectuals and they will then open a secure Web site to collect signatures. [...]
The petition, which has already become the target of nationalists, has led to criticism from other intellectuals.
Aytekin Yıldız, the coordinator of the Confrontation Association (Yüzleşme Derneği), pointed out that the Armenian community was already aware of the fact that there are many people in Turkey of conscience, and the important thing was not to declare what is already known. “It is a good starting point, but not enough. Firstly, what do they mean by ‘great disaster’? Let’s name it, it is genocide. Secondly, the state has to apologize,” Yıldız pointed out. [...]
I mentioned earlier that I kind of lost my faith in petitions. I think they could be potentially effective if there is similar to the UK system when government responds to all petitions submitted. However, I support civil intiatives aimed at democracy and human rights in Armenia.
Below is a call to sign a petition in relation to recent amendements approved by Armenian parliament to restrict the freedom of rallies:
On April 15-16 Members of Parliament of Republic of Armenia together with international experts will be discussing the changes of the law "On conducting meetings, assemblies, rallies and demonstrations" introduced on March 17 of 2008.
If you are a citizen of Armenia who considers these changes as severe limitations imposed on the freedom of assemblies that need to be immediately repealed, you are welcome to sign the petition calling Armenian parliament to do so at http://www.gopetition.com/online/18434.html.
A Petition to End Violence in Armenia (via Blogian)
We, people who care about Armenia and democracy, are calling on Armenia’s authorities to immediately end violence against presidential election protesters in Yerevan.
via Blogrel - (AFP reports) The OSCE said Sunday it had sent a mediator to Armenia, where eight people have been killed [Unzipped - CNN reports 9 have been killed] in protests against the alleged rigging of a presidential election, and appealed for both sides to show restraint.Finnish diplomat Heikki Talvitie was to arrive in the Armenian capital on Sunday, the Organisation for Security and ooperation in Europe presidency said in a statement. “I have sent my special envoy to try to bring both sides to the negotiating table and to find a way out of this crisis through political dialogue,” Finnish Foreign Minister Ilkka Kanerva said in the statement. Finland currently holds the OSCE presidency.
A shameful response from the Prime Minister office
As a signee of a petition to British PM to recognise the Armenian Genocide of 1915 (petition was signed by 1 136 British residents), I just received a response from the 10 Downing Street:
"You signed a petition asking the Prime Minister to "Recognise the Armenian Genocide of 1915."
Here is British Government's response in full. It is Denial without boarders... and without shame. A pure disgrace!
"The British Government acknowledges and regrets the terrible events that afflicted the Ottoman Armenian population at the beginning of the last century, when over a million ethnic Armenian citizens of the Ottoman Empire were killed. Many were massacred; some were victims of civil strife, starvation and disease, which ravaged the whole population of Eastern Anatolia during the First World War.
The massacres were an appalling tragedy, which the British Government of the day condemned. We fully endorse that view. However, neither this Government nor previous British Governments have judged that the evidence is sufficiently unequivocal to persuade us that these events should be categorised as genocide as defined by the 1948 UN Convention on Genocide, a convention which is, in any event, not retrospective in application.
The British Government believes that the focus should be on ensuring a progressive approach; to improve the chances for reconciliation between Armenian and Turkish people and to achieve a peaceful and secure future for everyone living in the region. To this end we encourage the Governments of Armenia and Turkey to improve co-operation, economic development and understanding between their countries.
In preparing for EU accession, Turkey must demonstrate its commitment to good neighbourly relations and must have undertaken to resolve outstanding border disputes. The advancement of accession negotiations will be guided by progress made in these, and other areas."
More than two-dozen prominent Armenians in the Diaspora have signed a statement supporting equality and justice for all in Armenia. Among th...
Quote of the moment
Մարտիրոս Սարյան: "Իմ կարծիքով, մեզ՝ որպես արևելյան ժողովրդի, չափազանց կպատշաճեր բազմագույն դրոշը, որն ի հայտ է բերում ինքը` չքնաղ և հավերժ գեղեցիկ ծիածանը:"(source)